Highlights

• Successfully defended a termite/pest control company in a week-long arbitration in which the arbitrator ruled in favor of the company and found the owner of an historic commercial building was not entitled to any damages since there was insufficient proof that any acts or omissions of the termite company caused any infestation or damages to the structure.
• Served as co-counsel with the Huie Fernambucq and Watkins & Eager firms in a two-week wrongful death products liability trial where the Estate of the decedent claimed a vehicle was not crashworthy after a frontal collision small overlap crash resulted in the death of the driver.
• Served as co-counsel with the Watkins Eager firm in a products liability case for an automobile manufacturer to obtain a defense verdict in the Circuit Court of Mobile County.
• Obtained a defense verdict in favor of a trucking company in a case involving a motor vehicle accident, alleging the truck driver caused the subject collision by negligently failing to yield the right-of-way, resulting in the plaintiff to suffer physical injuries and mental anguish.
• Secured favorable Supreme Court opinion on behalf of termite and pest control company in a case involving claims of fraud, negligence, wantonness, and breach of contract.
• Obtained summary judgment and complete dismissal on behalf of termite company in Mobile County Circuit Court on claims of fraud, negligence, wantonness, and breach of contract.
• Obtained complete summary judgment and dismissal of all claims in favor of a national retailer on an open and obvious theory wherein the Plaintiff allegedly tripped and fell on a metal barricade and sustained a broken arm.

• Obtained a favorable opinion from the Supreme Court of Alabama reversing and remanding a trial court’s denial of a client’s request to compel arbitration of claims filed against his business in Baldwin County, Alabama.
• Obtained complete summary judgment in favor of reginal grocery store chain on claims for negligence related to a slip and fall incident.
• Obtained a defense verdict in an insurance coverage dispute alleging that the plaintiff qualified as a resident relative under his sister’s UM/UIM insurance policy.
• Obtained dismissal of a defamation suit against a corporate media defendant in the U. S. District Court for the Southern District of Alabama for lack of personal jurisdiction.
• Obtained complete summary judgment in federal district court on behalf of surety/bonding company, dismissing claims which alleged that surety was responsible for damages arising out of the nonpayment of various subcontractors by the owner of a condominium development on Gulf Coast.
• Obtained dismissal on behalf of marine services client of pendent state law claims in federal district court, which alleged claims of breach of contract, fraud, and unpaid accounts in connection with the purchase of a vessel and various other marine services contracts.
• Obtained dismissal in federal district court, on behalf of horticulture corporation, of fraud and negligence claims, as well as 31 patent claims based upon statute of limitations and laches arguments.
• Obtained a summary judgment in favor of a nursing home in a wrongful death case where the plaintiff’s decedent alleged that the nursing personnel breached the standard of care in their treatment of the resident.
• Obtained a defense verdict in the U. S. District Court for the Southern District of Alabama in a personal injury case filed against an insured for damages allegedly sustained by Plaintiff as a result of a motor vehicle accident.
• Obtained summary judgment on behalf of three co-employee defendants on claims asserted against them for willful misconduct by their fellow employee for the alleged failure to install, repair and/or maintain a safety device while operating a forklift in a plant for a national paper mill factory.
• Obtained dismissal of international hotel chain from premises liability suit, based on fact that hotel chain was not responsible for operation or maintenance of hotel where incident occurred.
• Obtained dismissal of claims against condominium developer based on argument that Mississippi chancery Court lacked jurisdiction to revisit decision of arbitrator.  The dismissal was affirmed on appeal by the Mississippi Court of Appeals.
• Obtained summary judgment on claims of defamation and outrage against retail store manager by former employee related to termination of the employee.
• Obtained complete summary judgment in purported class action suit brought against cable services provider for breach of contract and specific performance arising out of gas rebate promotion.  The dismissal was subsequently affirmed on appeal by the Alabama Supreme Court.
• Obtained complete summary judgment on behalf of home health care agency and certified nursing assistant, where Plaintiff alleged claims of medical negligence, assault, breach of contract, and negligent hiring, training, and supervision, arising out of alleged improper handling of mentally ill patient.
• Obtained defense verdict on behalf of cable services provider in state court action in Baldwin County, where Plaintiff alleged damages related to breach of contract and negligent installation of cable services, causing him lost rental value on his condominium unit in Gulf Shores, Alabama.

Load More

Presentations and Publications

• Next Level Lawyering by IADC Trial Directors : a Podcast Series Focused on Trials, presented by the IADC Trial Techniques and Tactics Committee (2026). 
• Initial Considerations in Defending a Lawsuit.  DRI, The Guide – A Young Lawyer’s Guide to Defense Practice (2014).
• Piercing the Corporate Veil – Alabama Nursing Home Association, Biloxi, MS   (October 27, 2014).

News & Insights

• 36 STARNES ATTORNEYS LISTED IN BEST LAWYERS IN AMERICA 2027
• SDF’s Axon, Butler, Ezelle & McCall Named 2026 “Best Lawyers of the Year”
• 35 Starnes Attorneys Listed in Best Lawyers in America 2026
• SDF’s Axon, Bates & Butler Named Best Lawyers “2025 Lawyer of the Year”
• 33 Starnes Attorneys Listed in Best Lawyers in America 2025
• Starnes Davis Florie Achieves Multiple Appellate Victories
• Warren Butler to Serve as Director of the 2024 IADC Trial Academy
• Starnes Attorneys Warren Butler & Kirby Howard Obtain Defense Award in Week-Long Arbitration
• SDF’s Warren Butler Obtains Defense Verdict in a 2- Week Wrongful Death Products Liability Trial
• Starnes Attorney Warren Butler Obtains Defense Verdict in Products Liability Case
• 30 Starnes Attorneys Listed in Best Lawyers in America 2024
• SDF’s Warren Butler Serves as Director-Elect at the 2023 IADC Trial Academy
• SDF’s Warren Butler has been inducted into the National Academy of Distinguished Neutrals (NADN)
• SDF’s Butler & Hines Obtain Defense Verdict for Trucking Company
• 16 Starnes Attorneys Listed in the 2022 Edition of Mid-South Super Lawyers
• 30 SDF ATTORNEYS LISTED IN BEST LAWYERS IN AMERICA 2023
• Warren Butler Appointed Director-Elect of the 2023 IADC Trial Academy
• STARNES ATTORNEYS BUTLER & HINES OBTAIN FAVORABLE RULING
• Favorable Alabama Supreme Court Ruling for Newton, Butler & Still
• Starnes Attorneys Butler, Whillock & Hines Obtain Favorable Ruling From Alabama Supreme Court